• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Cathy Cake's Main Street Station - Cozy Wisconsin Eatery Known for Outstanding Sandwiches and Homemade Breads

Cathy Cake's Main Street Station, nestled in Wild Rose, Wisconsin, offers a warm, cozy spot where homemade flavors shine. Renowned for freshly baked breads like jalapeño cheddar, and exceptional sandwiches including one of the best French dips around, this local gem highlights quality meats and comforting dishes. Regulars praise the generous portions, delicious chili, and standout rhubarb bars, reflecting true neighborly hospitality. The inviting atmosphere and scratch-made cooking bring a sense of home to every meal. Though only open on weekdays, Cathy Cake's is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic, heartfelt food crafted with care and passion.

Cathy Cake's Main Street Station at a glance

  • Address 465 Main St, Wild Rose, WI 54984, United States
  • Phone +1 920-622-3999
  • Restaurant type Restaurant , Breakfast restaurant , Sandwich shop .
  • Popular for Breakfast , Lunch , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Cathy Cake's Main Street Station: Reviews & Ratings

Bryan Vermeersch
5

I would like to see them accept debit cards. But the food is outstanding

Sheila Brockett
5

This is my official go to for lunch! Cathy makes a variety of breads, and makes one of the best french dips I have ever eaten. Yesterday, I had jalapeño cheddar bread for my sandwich. She has 1/2 size sandwich that is more than a person can eat. I also tried the chili and really liked it too. Her meat seems to be better quality than what I have had here at other Wisconsin restaurants. I travel 11 miles to eat here, and it is well worth the drive! I have not had breakfast yet, will have to let you know later. I believe in quality, good tasting food and this is a great place to eat.

matthew Widowski
5

A wonderful place, relaxing, cozy atmosphere! The food is excellent!! I wish there were more place like this in the world. Homemade cooking just like mom makes.

Lydia Meulemans
5

Got 2 sandwiches that were absolutely delicious. Never have I ever tasted a sandwich that good! Got coffee too and a rhubarb bar that was also super good!

Jeff Laakso
5

Great sandwiches make sure to order during the week not open on weekends

Terry L
5

Very good service and food was plentiful and delicious! A great small town atmosphere with very friendly people. We enjoyed the entire experience from start to finish! It was our first time eating here, will definitely return again when in this area. Oh, and try the Hot Fudge Sundae, huge, delicious and filling! Just have cash or check, they don't take credit cards. Highly recommend!

Sue Donarski
4

The bread they use for their sandwiches is delicious! Excellent sandwiches. Try blueberry cheesecake torte was homemade and super yummy.

Jason Contreras
5

I don't know where Sue is coming from with that 4 star rating... I guess atmosphere??? But are we really going to a small sandwich shop to base a rating on that.... Ehhhh, I wouldn't imagine so. And Jack Martin, your review made it sound like you'd be fun at parties.. not. Anyways, I would like to start my review by saying, thank you to the wonderful ladies that have been there since I can remember making the delicious food. It has and is, by far my favorite spot to go when I have the time to catch them on their business hours. And when I do I have never been disappointed. I've brought friends from all over the country here when they visit and they have all agreed, some of the best and freshest food you will have. And I believe a lot of that credit goes to those ladies! Everything seems to always be well balanced and filling. Not too much, not too little. This is the hidden gem of this area. Cathy Cakes Main Street Station is always my first recommendation to those visiting Waushara County!* *So, If you're reading this, this is your sign to go get you some great food!

Location

  • Cathy Cake's Main Street Station
    Cathy Cake's Main Street Station
    465 Main St, Wild Rose, WI 54984, United States Hotline: +1 920-622-3999

Located in the heart of Wild Rose, Wisconsin, Cathy Cake's Main Street Station is a charming eatery that feels like coming home. This cozy spot on Main Street is famed for its homemade cooking that echoes the warmth and simplicity of a mother’s kitchen. From the moment you step inside, the inviting atmosphere sets the stage for a memorable meal.

What truly sets Cathy Cake's apart is the exceptional quality and variety of its breads, lovingly crafted with care. Customers rave about unique options like the jalapeño cheddar bread, which perfectly complements the hearty sandwiches. The French dip sandwich stands out as a must-try—a masterful blend of savory meat and rich flavors that keeps patrons coming back, even from 11 miles away.

The menu offers more than sandwiches, with highlights such as a well-seasoned chili and delectable rhubarb bars that deliver both comfort and a touch of sweetness. The meat quality here surpasses many local competitors, adding depth and satisfaction to every bite. Pairing your meal with a freshly brewed coffee rounds out the experience, turning an ordinary lunch into a treasured ritual.

While the establishment currently does not accept debit cards and is closed on weekends, the food’s outstanding reputation and the warm, homey ambiance make it worth planning a weekday visit. Cathy Cake’s Main Street Station is more than just a place to eat; it’s a destination for honest, quality food that delights and comforts with every dish.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards